Why Mennonite Mutual?

In 1895 a community was built with strong faith, farms, ministries, and families. Values were well established, and creativity was as necessary for success as hard work.

Now, over 120 years since Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company was established we understand that though much has changed, doing good business and building a strong community of partners requires that same creativity, hard work and adherence to well established Core Values


Since 1895, we’ve specialized in church and farm insurance, providing the ultimate personalized service and value with our network of local, independent agents throughout Indiana and Ohio. With a Best’s Rating of A- (Excellent), you can rest assured that your assets will be covered, and your property well protected.


Our Mission Statement

“Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company provides products and services for the protection and assurance of our policyholders and agents.”

Our Vision Statement

“The insurer of choice for faith and agribusiness based clients/partners.”


We honor God through these core values: 

“Best in Class" Mindset

  • Better today than we were yesterday
  • Market-focused products and services
    1 Corinthians 12:31 But earnestly desire the higher gifts. And I will show you a still
    more excellent way.

Relationship Driven

  • Integrity, trust and respect in all we do
  • Create and maintain strong personal connections
    Luke 6:31 And as you wish that others would do to you, do so to them.

Attitude of Service

  • Listen, respond and deliver to our partners
  • Treat the Agribusiness Risks and Faith-Based Ministries we protect as our own
    1 Peter 4:10 As each has received a gift, use it to serve one another, as good stewards
    of God’s varied grace.

Stewardship of Resources

  • Invest in what increases value for our partners and in our people, helping them
    realize their full potential
  • Give generously of our talents and resources to those who need it most
    Proverbs 3:9 Honor the Lord with your wealth and with the firstfruits of all you produce.

Our team of insurance experts has the background, education, and training to assist you in securing the right coverage.

Mennonite Mutual Insurance
1000 S. Main Street,
Orrville, OH 44667
Copyright © 2020 Mennonite Mutual Insurance. All rights reserved.