Careers at Mennonite Mutual

Apply Now



Open Positions


No positions are currently available. We encourage you to check back for future opportunities to join our team.

Not Your Average Insurance Job

As an employee at an insurance company, you might feel like most days the mission is paperwork - getting a policy issued or a claim resolved.

Our mission is different. 

With a career at Mennonite Mutual, you join an insurance company — a family — that’s on a sincere mission to honor God by strengthening, protecting, and restoring churches and farms - making the insurance world and policyholders’ lives better.


    • 401K and company match program
    • Profit-Sharing Bonus
    • Vacation days
    • Paid day of service
    • Paid time off for birthday
    • Health Insurance
    • Disability Insurance
    • Life Insurance
    • Vision Insurance
    • Employee Assistance Program
    • Generous Employer Health Savings deposit
    • Remote work program
    • Flexible work schedule
    • Family-oriented
    • Company-sponsored outings
    • Professional Development
    • Tuition reimbursement
    • Job training & conferences 
    • Designation incentive program
    • Wellness Reimbursement Program


  • "Best in Class" Mindset
  • Focused on Building Meaningful Relationships
  • Attitude of Service
  • Stewardship of Resources

Our Mission Statement

To honor God by strengthening, protecting, and restoring churches and farms in the communities we serve.

Multi-generational families entering church doors into lobby

mennonite mutual icon

We’ve Been Protecting Farmers and Faith-Based Organizations for Generations

Located in Orrville, Ohio, Mennonite Mutual serves the needs of faith-based organizations and agribusiness-based clients. Through seasons of prosperity and seasons of challenge, we provide a constant source of personalized service and value.

grandfather and granddaughter driving tractor in field

Interested in joining the Mennonite Mutual family?

To apply for a position, submit your resume to:

Mennonite Mutual Insurance
1000 S. Main Street,
Orrville, OH 44667
Copyright © 2024 Mennonite Mutual Insurance. All rights reserved.