Hard work, deep faith, a creative spirit, and the value of community have been at the heart of Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company ever since it was founded by J.M. Smucker in 1895. We’ve specialized in church and farm insurance ever since, providing the ultimate personalized service and value with our network of local, independent agents throughout Indiana and Ohio.
Building a strong network of partners requires the same creativity, hard work, and adherence to core values that built our community 120 years ago. Our commitment has earned us a Best’s Rating of A- (Excellent) as we continue to protect the interests and assets of agricultural and faith-based professionals.