About

Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company offers comprehensive property/casualty insurance products in small cities, towns, and rural communities throughout Ohio and Indiana. We specialize in serving churches, farms and small businesses. Our company was founded on the motto, “bear ye one another’s burdens.” (Galatians 6:2). Today, we are still clinging to the basic principles of our founders.

Over the years, we have become known as a “caring” company—caring about our policyholders, our independent agents, our employees and the communities in which we serve; going the “second mile” to provide prompt service and to answer your questions. We are small enough to give you individual personal attention, but we also have the needed financial capacity, along with excellent reinsurance contracts, to provide you with the peace of mind and protection that is so necessary for today’s world.

Our products, along with quality personal attention, are provided through highly qualified and professional Independent Insurance Agents.

The specialized products we offer:

  • Stewardship Protection Program (for traditional churches)
  • Ministry Assistance Program (for non-traditional churches, religious schools, church camps, daycare or childcare, and other faith-based organizations)
  • Farmowners / Agribusiness Program
  • Businessowners Program

Other products offered to complete accounts:

  • Farm / Commercial Excess Liability (Umbrella)
  • Equipment / Systems Breakdown coverage
  • Commercial Auto coverage
  • Equine coverage

Our Home Office is located at: 1000 South Main Street, Orrville, OH 44667. Feel free and contact us at 1-800-678-6885 or 330-682-2986. You can also reach out to us via email: info(at)mennonitemutual.com. For helpful insight and news you can use, “Like” us on Facebook www.facebook.com/mennonitemutual or follow us on Twitter @mennonitemutual.